|
The Newsletter |
READ ALL ABOUT IT! SUBSCRIBE TO OUR FREE, QUARTERLY E-NEWSLETTER Our newsletter seeks to inform, but also to delight. We embrace the quirky, the profound and the beautiful, always with an eye to Canadian content. Suggestions for future content related to exhibitions, book launches and other events are welcome, pending available space and timing of the event. Please send suggestions and requests to newslettercsda@csda-ccad.org The archive of past newsletters is available in the Member Portal. |
CURATOR'S CORNERDavid Daley, Conservation Advisor for Special Collections in Libraries and Cultural Resources at the University of Calgary LibraryModeling for the Future: The Treatment of Douglas Cardinal’s Model for the Canadian Museum of History |
Over the past five years, a project to clean and repair the architectural models of the Canadian Architectural Archives (CAA) at the University of Calgary has been underway. The treatment project will increase access for researchers, students, and the general public. The CAA collection includes the first concept model for the National Museum of Man (now called the Canadian Museum of History (CMH)) by celebrated Alberta Métis architect Douglas Cardinal. As work to repair the models progressed, the treatment of the CMH model stood out as an example of how an object treatment can be about much more than just repairing an artifact.

Photo of Douglas Cardinal, 1989. Courtesy of the Estate of Yousuf Karsh.
Douglas Cardinal is a well-known Canadian architect, widely recognized for his curvilinear buildings and organic forms. Born in Calgary in 1934 and raised near Red Deer, Alberta, his father was a game warden of Blackfoot ancestry and his mother was of German and Métis ancestry. By the 1980s, his firm had designed many international and western Canadian buildings, but the higher-profile project work needed to increase his professional reputation in central Canada hadn’t materialized. That changed when his 1983 submission statement for the new national museum impressed Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau and ultimately led to his firm’s successful bid.
Before work could begin to clean and repair the model, background research was conducted to learn more about it. The photographic record was investigated ‒ in-house photos taken at the university when the model was acquired, and a few historic images of the new building proved critical to inform and guide the restoration project. A thorough examination was carried out to help create a condition report which explained what the model was made of, how it was constructed, and what actions were needed to preserve it.
1992 photo of the model taken after acquisition shows a heavy dust layer, surface damage and toy vehicles. Douglas Cardinal fonds, Canadian Architectural Archives, University of Calgary. Used with permission.
The model reflects the initial design concept of a single building divided into two halves. A central atrium contained a series of waterfalls descending toward the Ottawa river. The model had sustained notable damage, much of it likely owing to its heavy weight and an untold number of storage locations since it was used to plan the museum. The atrium skylight was gone, and many other parts appeared to be lost. In-house photos from the 1990s indicated that it was cleaned after acquisition and that some of the damage and loss had occurred since it was acquired. There’s an upside to this which I’ll explain later. It was unclear if two toy vehicles seen in the file photos actually belonged to the model.

Re-adhering a detached part to the surface of the model. Photo by Rob Alexander. Douglas Cardinal fonds, Canadian Architectural Archives, University of Calgary. Used with permission.
The model is comprised of two major sections. A heavy base structure with a wooden underframe supports the building, river and landscape features on top. The museum building and terrain are made of multiple layers of plastic sheet glued on top of each other, and the buildings at the back along Laurier Street are made of painted wooden blocks.
Major losses include the trusses over the bridge to Ottawa, the window mullions (vertical supports) over the atrium and along the building face, and three flagpoles. Long horizontal strips of clear plastic were originally between the tiered floors to represent the panoramic windows of the museum, and many of those are lost, too. An early photo on the CMH website also showed the model illuminated from within, which explains why there were holes drilled up through the base and into the building. The internal wiring and lighting system is no longer there, and the model underframe is broken on one side. Consequently, it can’t be handled without risking further damage.
The upside to the damage was that many detached parts were still on hand. To prepare for the treatment, I checked a box of dissociated model parts for matching pieces. The box yielded the toy vehicles seen in earlier University of Calgary file photos, the large rectangular white building missing from the back corner, and other important pieces. Keeping the broken debris that had been recovered from temporary storage areas over the years proved to be well worth the effort. Other, smaller parts were also found within the recesses of the model. These were removed, listed, cleaned, and placed in numbered bags before trying to determine where they belonged.
Overhead view of the model after being lifted onto storage support. Model is in the final stages of treatment. Photo by David Daley. Douglas Cardinal fonds, Canadian Architectural Archives, University of Calgary. Used with permission.
After an initial cleaning with soft brushes and a vacuum, a more thorough cleaning was carried out using a pH-neutral soap and distilled water. The detached plastic and wooden parts were re-adhered with a reversible glue. The wood breaks on the right side of the base frame aren’t easily repaired because the understructure has large knots through it where the corner screws are set. Setting new screws into it would not impart any strength and a more elaborate repair would be complicated and highly interventive. Another solution was required. The toy vehicles are ridiculously out of scale with the model, but preservation colleagues informed me that the very same cars accompany Douglas Cardinal models in other collections. The vehicles were recorded as belonging to the model and stored separately for safekeeping.
Model with protective cover before placement in storage. Photo by David Daley. Douglas Cardinal fonds, Canadian Architectural Archives, University of Calgary. Used with permission.
Because the model is structurally unsound and handling incurs the risk of further damage, a sturdy plywood support was built for storage and handling. It has guards to hold the model in place, and a black plastic cover to protect it from light and dust. The model support was painted white to seal the wood and help keep it clean. Two long bands of cotton strapping were laid between the support and model to allow it to be lifted off for further treatment and repair in the future. As so often is the case with conservation treatments, a balance had to be struck between the ideal procedure and what is realistic, considering general time constraints and other conservation projects already underway.
As the treatment wound down, I couldn’t help but reflect on how working with the model has been a fascinating and informative endeavour. Conservators are fortunate to have the unique chance to be a part of the lives of objects that will outlive us all. Our role requires us to consider the past, present, and future of the items which we work to preserve. In the future, perhaps someone can pick up where I left off and add reproductions of the lost parts to bring the model closer to the architect’s original work. The replacement of the lost parts would go a long way toward restoring the integrity of the object for teaching and exhibition. It would also be great to see it rewired for internal illumination to show what the building looks like at night when its lights reflect on the Ottawa river.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHYDavid Daley is a mixed collections conservator and Conservation Advisor for Special Collections in Libraries and Cultural Resources at the University of Calgary Library. |